| Question | Pass | Fail |
| Visual edit (V) |
Removal: the target object is gone for the whole clip, no recognisable remnant or ghost. Addition: the target object is visibly present, looks like the thing named, and stays coherent over the clip (no flicker, duplication, identity switch). |
Object still (partly) visible / reappears; or (addition) missing, wrong object, flickering, incoherent. |
| Acoustic edit (A) |
Removal: the target's sound is gone for the whole clip (faint leaks or short bursts count as Fail). Addition: a sound appropriate to the target is clearly audible and coherent. |
Sound of the target still audible / returns; or (addition) missing, wrong sound, isolated burst. |
| Visual preservation (Pvis) |
Everything that should stay (other objects, people, their motion, the visible background) is kept. Changes that follow naturally from the edit (e.g. the object's shadow disappearing, a hand that held it now empty) are OK. |
Unrelated regions damaged, people/objects altered, background changed, large areas blurred. |
| Audio preservation (Paud) |
The non-target sounds of the source (voices, music, ambience) are still there and sound the same. |
Other sounds removed, muted, replaced or clearly changed. Choose NA when the source has no non-target sound you could check. |
| Artifacts (visual / audio) |
None: nothing new. Minor: Major: |
| Reconstruction plausible (removal only) |
The region where the object was now shows a plausible scene (background continues sensibly). |
A blurry patch, a hole, smeared texture, or an implausible object stands where the target was. |
| A/V consistency (C) (only asked for some items) |
First say whether this output gives you enough evidence to check it (a visible action that should make a sound, or a sound with a visible source). If yes: the visible action and the sound match in time and kind. |
Clear lead/lag, a sound continuing through an incompatible action, a sound-producing action without its sound. |
Consistency pre-pass
You will see the source clip and the instruction only (no outputs). Answer one question per item: after this edit, would a correctly edited clip still contain an event whose sound and visible action can be checked against each other?
Think of a visible action that produces sound (an instrument being played, a car driving by, a dog barking on screen). Answer No when the only checkable event is the target of a removal and nothing else sounding remains, or when the clip is static/ambient.